• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Good Books
  • Tools
  • Blog
  • Darren
  • Contact
  • Hire Me
Small Biz Geek

Small Biz Geek

Small Business Design, Marketing & Technology Journal

Solving small business design, marketing & tech problems

  • The Internet
  • Marketing
  • Graphic Design
  • Web Dev
  • Web Design
  • Social Media
  • Privacy & Security
  • Tech
  • Misc

Net Neutrality: Do We Need It?

Published: March 3, 2015; Updated: April 15, 2017 Filed Under: Featured, Internet

The US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) are implementing internet regulation rules to maintain a level playing field for both business and consumer.

The online community calls this Net Neutrality.

Highway traffic blocked

The internet represents experimentation and quick decision making without the worry of high costs or logistical problems found in larger organisations.

Small businesses have never had it so good. This is until the entities controlling broadband internet subscriptions try to throttle it.

Seth Godin calls these choke points.

 

The philosophy is that internet access should never be monopolized by those with vast resources. By disallowing pay-to-play cyber “fast lanes” there cannot be any opportunities for exploitation.

In theory, we should all enjoy fast download speeds. That’s the idea, anyway.

Broadband Reclassified

The FCC are now treating broadband internet services as a utility. In 2005 broadband was classified as an “information” service, but because of the gradual changes to the way the world uses the web, broadband services are to be regarded as “telecommunications” services.

The three principles of the FCC regulation are:

  • Transparency
  • No blocking
  • No unreasonable discrimination

On Saturday 28th February the FCC announcement on a forthcoming 332 317 page document was made: FCC Adopts Strong, Sustainable Rules to Protect the Open Internet.

The activists see the neutrality regulations as a hard won victory after a 2014 court ruling swung in favour of Verizon, the ISP provider who sued the FCC over the 2010 Open Internet Order.

The FCC’s 2010 order was intended to prevent broadband ISP’s from blocking/interfering with web traffic but the proposed legal foundations never stood up to scrutiny.

We may not notice any discernible performance changes because the internet has always been open. What we don’t want is for the internet to turn into a closed system resembling cable TV where content is controlled or blocked.

Most Internet Service Providers have affiliates or partners, such as search engines, and will often push these services aggressively.

For example, in the UK, Virgin Media is partnered with the Yahoo! search engine.

Although the FCC doesn’t have any influence in the UK, it makes me wonder how similar situations in the US will be handled.

What about illegal content and file sharing? Will that continue?

My ISP currently blocks torrent websites, but not torrent sites in and of themselves aren’t illegal. It’s the content that’s shared.

Radiohead famously released their In Rainbows album for free in 2008 and made revenue from voluntary fan donations.

Does this mean internet providers in the United States will have to stop throttling torrent sites? Will there be a trickledown effect to Europe and the UK?

The video below is a 3 minute explanation of what is happening. Quite a few niggling details have been left out but I’m sure you just want the basics:

Watch video on YouTube

This move will supposedly protect the open internet although it has attracted criticism from a FCC Commissioners, one Ajit Pai who represents the Republican party.

As an aside, the FCC is directed by five commissioners and only three may be members of the same political party. These individuals are appointed by the President of the US and approved by the Senate. Interestingly, the Democrats have the ruling majority within the FCC but that’s just my observation.

Cyberspace Empire

Bizarrely, as part of his criticism, Ajit Pai quoted Senator Palpatine aka The Emperor from Return of the Jedi using the line: “Young fool, only now at the end do you understand.”

Ajit Pai clearly feels the future of the internet is now even less certain thanks to the FCC. Mike O’Reilly, the other Republican FCC commissioner remarked, “When you see this document, it’s worse than you imagine.” I’m waiting for O’Reilly to give us a Darth Vader line.

  • The FCC announcement about the 332 317 page document is here: FCC Adopts Strong, Sustainable Rules to Protect the Open Internet.

It seems the open internet activists are going to bang the drum for openness and fairness whatever the document decrees.

The references to Star Wars, emperors and activists seem as though both sides are participating in a good vs. evil narrative.

I feel as though the Republicans (Empire) want to build a Death Star and the Democrats (rebels) want to stop it. There seems to be a partisan agenda the general public (Ewoks) do not understand.

Is This Bad for My Business?

On the face of it, I’m all for openness.

HOWEVER I want to know why the two FCC members representing the Republican party think this is a bad thing?

Are they toeing the party line or is there more to it that my anti Republican prejudices are stopping me from seeing? At the risk of sounding selfish, I need to know if Net Neutrality is bad for MY business.

Here’s a comparison to illustrate my concerns: on January 1st 2015 the EU saw new legislation passed to stop tax evasion by corporations operating in low VAT threshold regions of Europe.

While it’s a good idea in theory, small businesses have been swept along with the new Europe tax laws and now have an obligation to obey a new VAT system on digital downloads. Short sighted legislators with good intentions rarely dig deeply enough. Politicians pander to an electorate, not to the people.

So, what exactly is in the FCC regulations that is dividing opinion? What am I missing?

I watched some more videos online, including one in which Paul Joseph Watson from InfoWars believes websites may need federal approval to operate at all:

Watch video on YouTube

Assuming you’ve just watched the video above, read the article below…

Net neutrality secrecy: No one knows what the FCC approved (but Google has a good idea)

You can find lots of news on the subject online. Keep in mind much of it is biased because this subject is a political hot potato.

Here’s one more video I found on YouTube… and it’s awesome! The style and delivery is very creative but I’m not sure I agree with everything she says because the video was published in 2014:

Watch video on YouTube

It’s fair to say I have more questions than answers on this subject!

You Might Also Be Interested In...

  • Stolen Credit Card Email Scam Targets Small Businesses and Service Providers 💳
  • Boost Your Biz Using Local Web Directory Listings
  • Is Offline Marketing Still Relevant in a Digital World?

Filed Under: Featured, Internet Tagged With: Classification, Congress, FCC, Freedom, ISPs, Net Neutrality, Open Internet, Telecommunications, Utilities

About Small Biz Geek

I'm Darren, helping small businesses with design, marketing & tech.

Small Business Website Design

Do you need help with something web related?

Hire Me

Reader Interactions

Subscribe to Blog Feed by Email

Your email address won't be shared. You'll never be spammed. Check your inbox to confirm opt-in.

Add Your Thoughts Cancel reply

Your email address is safe and will NOT be shared with anyone else.

Hateful, spammy or abusive comments will not be tolerated.

For more information please see the comment policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search Website

Latest Blogs

  • Is Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) the Answer to the Future of Search? 🎨
  • How Hiding Your Phone Number and Using a Booking System Repels Time Wasters and Helps “Positioning” 🗓️
  • “Fucking Good Content” – Dan Kelsall (Book Review) 📘
  • Scam Poetry: The Time I Was Recruited to the Cult of Amway ⚠️
  • A Story of Seductive Social Media Success and Neglected Email Strategy 🏚️
  • The Classic Social Media Trend Destined to Ruin Your Business 😭
  • Looking for Online Work? Don’t Fall for this Fake Hays Recruitment WhatsApp Scam ⚠️
  • Cream of the Crap: How Fake Reviews, Bad Businesses and Dangerous Products Rise to the Top 💣
  • Exposed: The Hong Kong Investment “Fraud Recovery” Scammer Deceiving Victims 🤑
  • Computer Says No: Does Your Website Work for People with Disabilities? ♿
  • Chinese Tinder Profiles Are Using Photos of Pretty Girls to Scam “Investors” 💋
  • Small Biz Owners “Trapped” Using Email Addresses Belonging to Internet Service Providers 🪤
  • In the Pandemic, QR Codes are Finally Proving Worthy in the West 😷
  • Small Businesses Finally Start Marketing… and All It Took Was a Global Pandemic 🏁

Footer

Primary Navigation

Home
About Darren
Good Books
My Tools
Blog Posts
Hire Me
Contact Me

Derby & Nottingham Area

The Internet
Marketing
Graphic Design
Website Development
Website Design
Social Media
Technology
Miscellaneous
Privacy & Security

Let’s Connect

Twitter
YouTube
LinkedIn
RSS

Small Business Blog · Privacy Policy · Commenting Policy · Website Disclaimer · ICO number: ZA305900


Written and designed by Ilkeston Web Design

  • Home
  • Good Books
  • Tools
  • Blog
  • Darren
  • Contact
  • Hire Me